The Async-First Approach: Reducing Meeting Overload

Not everything needs to be a meeting. In fact, many things work better when they're NOT meetings. Here's how to embrace asynchronous communication.

What is Async Communication?

Asynchronous (or "async") communication means people contribute on their own time rather than simultaneously.

Synchronous (real-time):

Video calls

Phone calls

In-person meetings

Live chat conversations

Asynchronous:

Email

Shared documents

Project management tools

Recorded videos

Discussion threads

Why Async Matters

1. Respects Different Schedules

Not everyone is productive at the same time. Some people do their best work in the morning, others in the evening. Async lets everyone work when they're most effective.

2. Enables Deep Work

Meetings fragment the day. Async communication lets people batch their responses during designated times, preserving long blocks for focused work.

3. Creates a Written Record

Discussions in meetings often get forgotten or misremembered. Async communication automatically creates documentation.

4. Gives People Time to Think

In meetings, whoever speaks first or loudest often drives the decision. Async gives quieter team members time to formulate thoughtful responses.

5. Works Across Time Zones

For distributed teams, finding meeting times that work for everyone is painful. Async eliminates this problem entirely.

What Works Well Async

Status Updates

Instead of a daily standup meeting, use:

A shared doc where everyone posts updates

A Slack thread

A project management tool with daily check-ins

Everyone posts when convenient. Everyone reads when convenient.

Brainstorming

Async brainstorming often produces better ideas:

Create a shared doc with the challenge

Give people 24-48 hours to add ideas

Have a short meeting to discuss the best ones

People aren't limited by what they can think of in the moment.

Decision Documentation

After a decision is made, document it async:

What was decided

Why it was decided

Who made the decision

What happens next

This creates a record everyone can reference.

Code Reviews

Code reviews are naturally async. The reviewer examines code when they have time. The author responds when convenient. No meeting needed.

Feedback Collection

Instead of a meeting to gather feedback:

Share the proposal in a doc

Ask for comments by a specific date

Address the feedback

Make a decision

You get better feedback because people have time to think.

Project Updates

Weekly status meetings can become:

A weekly written update

Posted at a consistent time

Following a standard template

With space for questions and discussion

What Still Needs Meetings

Some things genuinely require real-time interaction:

Complex Problem Solving

When you need to rapidly iterate and bounce ideas off each other, a meeting (or at least a live discussion) is often faster.

Relationship Building

Especially for remote teams, some synchronous interaction helps build rapport and trust. Don't eliminate all human connection.

Urgent Situations

True emergencies or time-sensitive decisions often need real-time discussion.

Difficult Conversations

Performance issues, conflict resolution, or sensitive topics generally require the nuance of live conversation.

Creative Collaboration

Some types of creative work benefit from the energy of real-time collaboration.

How to Transition to Async-First

Step 1: Audit Your Meetings

List all your recurring meetings and ask:

What's the purpose?

Could this be async?

What would we lose?

What would we gain?

Step 2: Start With Easy Wins

Pick the meetings that are obviously async-friendly:

Status updates

FYI announcements

Information sharing

Convert these first to build confidence.

Step 3: Set Clear Expectations

For async communication to work, establish:

Expected response times (e.g., within 24 hours)

Where different types of communication should happen

How to indicate urgency

When to escalate to synchronous communication

Step 4: Create Templates

Standard formats make async communication efficient:

Status Update Template:

What I accomplished this week

What I'm working on next week

Where I'm blocked

Questions for the team

Decision Template:

What we're deciding

Background/context

Options we're considering

Deadline for input

How we'll decide

Step 5: Designate Async Channels

Be clear about what goes where:

Slack: Quick questions, time-sensitive updates

Email: Important but not urgent

Docs: Proposals, decisions, documentation

Project tools: Task-specific communication

Async Best Practices

1. Be Specific and Comprehensive

Without the ability to ask immediate follow-ups, your initial message needs to be complete:

Provide context

Be specific about what you need

Include relevant links/documents

Set clear deadlines

2. Use the Right Medium

Quick question? Chat

Need thoughtful input? Document

Sharing information? Email or doc

Collaborative editing? Shared doc with comments

3. Make it Easy to Skim

Use formatting to help:

**Bold key points**

Break into short paragraphs

Use bullet points

Add headers

Put the most important info first

4. Set Response Expectations

Be clear about urgency:

"No rush, respond when you can"

"Need input by Friday"

"Urgent, please respond today"

5. Close the Loop

When you get the info you need:

Acknowledge responses

Summarize decisions

Share outcomes

Don't leave threads hanging.

Common Async Pitfalls

Pitfall 1: Everything Becomes Urgent

If everything is "urgent," nothing is. Reserve urgent for actual urgencies.

Pitfall 2: No Deadlines

"Please review when you can" often means "never." Give specific deadlines.

Pitfall 3: Too Many Channels

If information is scattered across Slack, email, docs, and 3 different tools, no one can find anything. Consolidate.

Pitfall 4: Waiting for Perfection

Async doesn't mean over-communication. It's okay to send a quick message instead of a perfectly crafted document.

Pitfall 5: Never Meeting

Some things still need meetings. Async-first doesn't mean async-only.

Measuring Success

Track these metrics to see if async is working:

Number of meetings per week

Time spent in meetings

Response times to async requests

Team satisfaction with communication

Whether decisions are getting made

The Cultural Shift

Moving to async-first requires a culture change:

Old mindset:

"I need an answer now"

"Let's schedule a meeting to discuss"

"I'll ping you on Slack until you respond"

New mindset:

"I'll plan ahead so people have time to respond"

"Can we discuss this async first?"

"I'll give people time to think before following up"

Tools That Help

You don't need fancy tools, but these can help:

Documentation: Google Docs, Notion, Confluence

Project Management: Asana, Trello, Linear

Async Video: Loom for quick explanations

Discussion: Threads in Slack, Teams, or dedicated forums

Decision Making: Polls, voting features, comment threads

Starting This Week

Three things you can do this week:

1. Cancel one recurring meeting - Replace it with an async update format

2. Default to async - Before scheduling your next meeting, ask "could this be async?"

3. Set response expectations - Start indicating deadlines on your async requests

The Balance

The goal isn't to eliminate all meetings. It's to use the right tool for the job:

Async: for information sharing, status updates, and thoughtful input

Sync: for complex problem-solving, relationship building, and urgent matters

When you get this balance right, your meetings become more valuable and your team gets more time for focused work.

[Track Your Meeting Time →](/signup)